The Toxic Dynamics of the Golden Child and Scapegoat in Narcissistic Families

By Sybil Cummin, MA, LPC, ACS

Understanding the Consequences and How to Support Your Children
 
In families with a narcissistic parent, children often face unique challenges that can have lasting effects on their sense of self, relationships, and overall well-being. If you share children with your narcissistic ex-partner, it is likely that you have seen your children treated differently.

​One of the most prominent dynamics in these families is the designation of the “golden child” and the “scapegoat.”
 
Understanding the function of these roles for the narcissist and their consequences is crucial for protective parents who want to support their children and mitigate the harm caused by the narcissistic parent.

---

The Golden Child: A Blessing or a Curse?

The golden child is the one who can seemingly do no wrong in the eyes of the narcissistic parent. They receive more attention, praise, and tangible rewards. You might think that this role is a better place to be for your child; however, this status comes at a cost. The narcissistic parent often leverages the golden child's qualities for their own validation and ego boost, living vicariously through the child's achievements.

---

Consequences for the Golden Child

1. Perfectionism and anxiety: The golden child feels immense pressure to maintain their status, leading to perfectionistic tendencies and fear of failure.
2. Conditional love: They learn that love and acceptance are contingent upon their performance, which can harm their self-worth.
3. Loss of identity: To please the narcissistic parent, the golden child may suppress their authentic self and become a people-pleaser.
4. Potential for narcissistic traits: Being constantly praised and lacking a strong sense of self can lead to the development of narcissistic qualities.

 The Scapegoat: Bearing the Brunt of Blame

The scapegoat, on the other hand, is the child who bears the brunt of the narcissistic parent's negative projections. They often embody qualities that the narcissistic parent dislikes within themselves, leading to constant criticism, blame, and neglect. 
 
 Consequences for the Scapegoat

1. Internalized self-blame: The scapegoat may internalize the message that they are inherently bad or unworthy of love. 
2. Behavioral issues: The lack of attention and validation can manifest as withdrawn, depressive behaviors or acting out.
3. Boundary struggles: In their search for love and acceptance, the scapegoat may have difficulty setting healthy boundaries.
4. Resentment towards the golden child: The scapegoat may feel resentful of the golden child’s perceived advantages and preferential treatment.

Supporting Your Children as a Protective Parent

​As a protective parent, your role is crucial in counteracting the harmful effects of the narcissistic parent's behavior. Although it may seem like this is out of your control, there are things that you can do to help mitigate these effects for your children. Here are some ways you can support your children:

---

1. Celebrate their individuality: Encourage and validate your children’s unique qualities, interests, and accomplishments, regardless of the narcissistic parent's opinions.
2. Offer unconditional love: Make it clear that your love and acceptance are not contingent upon their achievements or behavior.
3. Validate their experiences: When your children express feelings of unfairness or mistreatment, acknowledge their emotions and avoid excusing the narcissistic parent's behavior.
4. Foster autonomy: Encourage your children to explore their interests, make age-appropriate decisions, and develop a strong sense of self.
5. Create a safe space: Provide a stable, consistent home environment where your children feel secure and valued for who they are.​ 

Navigating the dynamics of the golden child and scapegoat in a narcissistic family is challenging, but understanding these roles and their consequences is a critical first step. As a protective parent, your unconditional love, validation, and support can make a significant difference in your children's lives. By fostering their individuality, autonomy, and self-worth, you can help them build resilience and break free from the harmful patterns imposed by the narcissistic parent.

This topic is discussed in more detail in the below episode of The Rising Beyond Podcast.